The previous few months of Marie Antoinette’s life would have been terrifying. In 1793, she noticed the French monarchy abolished, her husband (King Louis XVI) executed, and her son taken from her as her nation descended into violence and bloodshed. Lastly, with simply in the future’s discover, she was taken from her jail cell and condemned to dying by guillotine. She was executed, alone, in entrance of a crowd cheering for her dying, only a few brief hours later.
That seems like sufficient to show your hair white, doesn’t it? And based on legend, that’s precisely what occurred.
“The primary time I noticed her majesty after the unlucky disaster of the Varennes journey [a botched escape attempt] … she took off her cap and desired me to watch the impact which grief had produced upon her hair,” Marie Antoinette’s lady-in-waiting Henriette Campan later recalled. “It had develop into, in a single single night time, as white as that of a girl of seventy.”
Canities subita, or “Marie Antoinette syndrome” because it was dubbed in a 2009 research paper, is about as controversial as the lady herself. Authenticated circumstances of hair immediately turning white or grey are extraordinarily rare; some scientists argue that it isn’t attainable in any respect.
“There are not any dwelling cells within the hair,” Desmond Tobin, Professor of Dermatological Sciences at College School Dublin, explained to Anne Jolis when her personal hair turned white. “Psychosocial stress can’t have an effect on the hair fiber that’s already fashioned, it might probably solely have an effect on the fibers as they’re forming.”
“It’s actually medically not possible; there isn’t a mechanism by which hair may organically flip white, both immediately or in a single day,” agrees a LiveScience article from 2012. “Even when an sickness, damage, or sudden shock may flip hair white, it could be weeks earlier than the impact can be seen as a result of solely the basis can be affected.”
And but, historical past appears filled with examples of individuals going immediately and prematurely grey after traumatic experiences. There’s the eponymous ex-queen herself, in fact; earlier than that, there was Thomas Extra, an English lawyer whose hair reportedly turned white the night time earlier than he was executed by Henry VIII for treason in 1535. The identical factor occurred to Mary, Queen of Scots earlier than her beheading, in addition to a handful of non-famous trauma survivors that made the medical literature.
For a very long time, the main clarification for the phenomenon was a situation referred to as alopecia areata. The thought was that stress may set off an auto-immune response, inflicting hair – and notably pigmented hair – to immediately fall out. Since unpigmented hair would usually be left unscathed, it could seem as if these with the situation had gone grey in a single day.
“It’s conceivable for an individual who tends for alopecia areata to undergo a annoying expertise which makes it aptitude up and the very first thing that occurs is their darkish hair falls out,” dermatologist David Orentreich advised NBC News again in 2009. “And that may occur rapidly – in days or perhaps weeks – leaving simply the grey hair.”
“There was solely a primitive understanding – if any understanding – of the immune system,” he continued. This lack of understanding would result in individuals looking for causes like shock or trauma to clarify the sudden desaturation, he defined.
However simply final yr, researchers lastly discovered a mechanism that may clarify the phenomenon. In a research revealed in Nature, researchers uncovered mice to varied stressors at totally different phases of hair progress. With every publicity, the researchers discovered that the rodents’ hair follicles misplaced the pigment-producing melanocyte stem cells, till finally the mice had been left with patches of Marie Antoinette-esque white fur.
“Once we began to check this, I anticipated that stress was dangerous for the physique – however the detrimental impression of stress that we found was past what I imagined,” senior writer Ya-Chieh Hsu advised the Harvard Gazette. “After only a few days, the entire pigment-regenerating stem cells had been misplaced. As soon as they’re gone, you may’t regenerate pigments anymore. The injury is everlasting.”
However the precise course of that led to pigment loss was nonetheless a thriller. Because the main speculation on the time was the autoimmune principle, the scientists tried stressing out mice with compromised immune programs – however hit a lifeless finish. Equally ill-fated was the investigation into whether or not the stress hormone cortisol was liable for the situation.
“Stress at all times elevates ranges of the hormone cortisol within the physique, so we thought that cortisol may play a task,” defined Hsu. “However surprisingly, once we eliminated the adrenal gland from the mice in order that they couldn’t produce cortisol-like hormones, their hair nonetheless turned grey below stress.”
However the adrenal gland isn’t the one place yow will discover stress hormones within the physique. Having dominated out cortisol because the offender, the researchers turned their consideration to noradrenaline, the primary neurotransmitter utilized by the sympathetic nervous system. That is the a part of the nervous system that regulates unconscious motion – most of us realize it as our fight-or-flight system.
“Acute stress, notably the fight-or-flight response, has been historically considered to be helpful for an animal’s survival,” lead writer Bing Zhang advised the Gazette. “However on this case, acute stress causes everlasting depletion of stem cells.”
“[W]e collaborated with many scientists throughout a variety of disciplines, utilizing a mixture of various approaches to resolve a really basic organic query,” Zhang mentioned.
So it could properly have been grief that turned Marie Antoinette’s hair white in any case – and now we all know how. Why, although, is one other matter – however based on neuroscientists Shayla Clark and Christopher Deppman, who wrote a commentary on the research however weren’t concerned within the analysis, the reply might lie in a few of our closest cousins.
“As a result of gray hair is most frequently linked to age, it may very well be related to expertise, management and belief,” they wrote. “For instance, grownup male silverback mountain gorillas … which get gray hair on their backs after reaching full maturity, can go on to steer a gorilla troop.”
“Maybe an animal that has endured sufficient stress to ‘earn’ gray hair has the next place within the social order than would ordinarily be conferred by that particular person’s age,” they urged.
This Week in IFLScience
Obtain our greatest science tales to your inbox weekly!